The British Nutrition Foundation welcomes the Scientific Advisory Committee on Nutrition’s (SACN) position statement, published on 10 November 2026, which clarifies how the UK definition of free sugars applies to processed fruit and vegetables. The advice was requested by the Department of Health and Social Care. The current definition available in the UK Nutrient Profiling Model (NPM) 2018 technical guidance and Swan et al 2018 is detailed but has led to questions regarding its application to specific processing methods.
We welcome this clarification, which should support more consistent application of the free sugars definition across policy, research and product development. SACN also recognises the practical challenges of calculating free sugars, particularly as most labelling shows total rather than free sugars. Clear and practical guidance will therefore be important to support robust and consistent implementation.
In the position statement, SACN has grouped processes by whether they are likely to release free sugars. Where fruit and vegetables have been liquidised, blended, pulped, sieved (to create juices, smoothies, pastes and juiced, purées), have undergone processes that produce concentrates, extruded products, powders, freeze dried and fully dehydrated products, or other processes, where the fruit or vegetables are no longer intact (e.g. mashing, pressing, crushing), the sugars they contain should be counted as free sugars. Simple processes such as chopping, slicing, dicing and grating, do not result in free sugars, nor does drying where the cellular structure remains largely intact. Stewed fruit and vegetables are considered to contain free sugars only where they are no longer intact. The definition applies equally to home cooking and manufactured products.
SACN is clear that these groupings clarify the existing 2018 UK definition rather than introduce a substantive change, and that its recommendations on free sugars intake remain unchanged. This added consistency will help to support the application of the free sugars definition in practice. We are pleased to see SACN’s explicit comparison of the UK definition with those of the WHO and EFSA. Setting out where these approaches align and differ is an important step towards a comprehensive definition, which is needed to navigate the current grey areas around what contributes to free sugars.
We recognise that this is a complex area. As SACN notes, evidence on how different processing methods affect the cellular structure of fruit and vegetables and the release of sugars is limited. We therefore agree that a pragmatic approach is needed. Where processing is considered to have broken down the cellular structure of fruit and vegetables, counting all naturally occurring sugars as free sugars is a reasonable way forward, rather than attempting to estimate the proportion released. This gives a clearer position, but some ambiguity may remain, particularly when labelling information is relied on to determine whether the cellular structure is still intact. We support SACN’s research recommendations to address these gaps. Of particular relevance would be methods to measure the impact of specific processing methods on the percentage of free sugars released from different fruit and vegetables.
SACN states that any overestimate of free sugars intakes resulting from this pragmatic approach is likely to be minimal. We welcome the analysis of the latest National Diet and Nutrition Survey (NDNS 2019 to 2023) data undertaken to inform this position statement. This provides useful context on the relative contribution of different sources of free sugars across age groups and by index of multiple deprivation (IMD), and shows that added sugars remain the main source of free sugars in the UK diet, while processed fruit and vegetable sources currently make a comparatively small contribution. Publication of the accompanying data tables is also helpful in providing insights on the contribution of individual sources, including added sugars, fruit juices and smoothies, fruit purées, and vegetable/fruit purées and juices, to free sugars intake.
We see this clarification as an important first step. As SACN notes, final decisions on how the definition is applied in policy rest with the UK government. We look forward to further practical guidance on implementation to address consistency and reproducibility in calculations, particularly within the proposed update to the UK NPM 2018 and its application to current promotion, placement and advertising restrictions. The British Nutrition Foundation is keen to continue working with government, academia and the food industry to support the practical application of this advice and to help create a healthier, more sustainable food environment for all.
About the British Nutrition Foundation
Connecting people, food and science for better nutrition and healthier lives
The British Nutrition Foundation is a charity that strives to prevent diet-related illness and promote health and wellbeing through evidence-based nutrition science. It provides a bridge between nutrition science, government, industry, healthcare, education and people, and is a conduit to a healthier, more sustainable food environment for all.
The British Nutrition Foundation’s team is made up of highly qualified and experienced nutrition scientists and educators who work to disseminate evidence-based peer reviewed research findings which: support industry strategy and healthy, sustainable product innovation; inform government policy and regulations; and help people build their knowledge, skills and confidence in making positive, food and lifestyle choices to help prevent illness and disease and promote health and wellbeing.
We safeguard our independence through robust governance, with an independent Board supported by an Advisory Committee and a Scientific Committee, both of which draw upon a broad range of experts from academia, government, industry, and public life. Our governance is weighted towards the scientific community, universities, and research institutes, and those from education, finance, media, communications, and HR backgrounds.
Funding for the British Nutrition Foundation is from membership subscriptions; donations; project grants from food producers and manufacturers, retailers and food service companies; conferences; publications, training, trusts, and foundations. The British Nutrition Foundation is not a lobbying organisation, nor does it endorse any products or engage in food advertising campaigns.
More details about the British Nutrition Foundation’s work, funding and governance can be found here.
Share this page